Part 2: The Mechanics and Ethics of Humor

 

Blog Series: Thoughts on Laughter and Humor

Introduction

In the first part of this series, we explored how laughter serves as a nervous reaction and a primitive form of communication, essential for diffusing social tensions and fostering group cohesion. In this second part, we delve into the nature of humor itself. Together we will now examine why some things are funny while others are not, and how humor can lead to both acceptance and dialogue, as well as why it can sometimes be perceived as offensive or in bad taste.

Laughter as a Diffuser of Tension

Building on the idea from our previous discussion, laughter acts as a social tool for diffusing tension. When a group of people experiences a shared tension, and a common reaction—laughter—emerges, it often leads to a sense of acceptance and unity. This shared experience can open the door to much-needed dialogue in more evolved social circumstances.

For instance, consider a group of people watching a comedian. The jokes might address societal issues or personal experiences that resonate with the audience. When everyone laughs, it not only reduces individual stress but also creates a collective sense of relief and understanding. This shared laughter can lead to a greater sense of community and, in some cases, spark important conversations about the topics being joked about.

The Anatomy of Humor

Humor is a complex and multifaceted phenomenon, but at its core, it often involves elements of surprise and the destabilization of expectations. Here’s a breakdown of how humor typically works:

1. Surprise: The element of surprise is crucial in humor. A punchline that catches us off guard or a situation that subverts our expectations can provoke laughter. This reaction is tied to the autonomic nervous system, which responds to unexpected stimuli with a sudden release of tension—manifested as laughter.

2. Destabilizing Ideas: Humor often involves presenting ideas in a way that destabilizes our usual way of thinking. This can include absurdity, incongruity, or exaggeration. For example, a joke might highlight the ridiculousness of everyday situations by exaggerating their characteristics, prompting us to see them from a new, humorous perspective.

These mechanisms are rooted in the same autonomic responses discussed in the first blog. When we laugh, it’s our body’s way of coping with the sudden shift in perception, releasing built-up tension and fostering social bonds.

High-Level Cognitive Function in Humor

Despite these automatic responses, humor also involves a high-level cognitive function that allows us to evaluate and decide whether we find something funny. This evaluation process considers various factors, including personal beliefs, social norms, and ethical considerations.

1. Taste and Sensitivity: We might find certain jokes to be in “bad taste” or insensitive, especially if they address topics that are painful or controversial. Humor that relies on stereotypes or targets vulnerable groups can be seen as offensive because it fails to consider the real-life implications and experiences of those being joked about.

2. Ethical Considerations: The destabilization effect of humor can highlight social injustices or absurdities, prompting reflection and dialogue. However, when humor reinforces harmful stereotypes or dismisses serious issues, it can perpetuate ignorance and insensitivity rather than fostering understanding.

For instance, jokes that make light of serious societal issues like racism, sexism, or mental health can be harmful because they trivialize the struggles of those affected. As a result, individuals may “decide” not to find such humor amusing, recognizing the potential harm it can cause.

Conclusion

Humor is a powerful tool that can diffuse tensions, foster social bonds, and provoke thoughtful dialogue. It relies on elements of surprise and the destabilization of expectations, rooted in our nervous system’s responses. However, our ability to evaluate and decide on the appropriateness of humor adds a layer of complexity, highlighting the ethical considerations involved in what we find funny.

Understanding the mechanics and ethics of humor helps us appreciate its role in society while also recognizing the responsibility that comes with it. By being mindful of the impact our jokes can have, we can use humor to bring people together, promote understanding, and create positive change.

Citations

1. Ruch, W., & Ekman, P. (2001). The Nature of Laughter: Mechanisms and Implications. Journal of Neuroscience.
2. Wild, B., Rodden, F. A., & Grodd, W. (2003). Neural correlates of laughter and humor. Brain.
3. Clay, Z., & de Waal, F. B. M. (2013). Development of socio-emotional competence in bonobos. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
4. Blakemore, S.-J., Wolpert, D., & Frith, C. (1998). Central cancellation of self-produced tickle sensation. Nature Neuroscience.
5. Mobbs, D., Greicius, M. D., Abdel-Azim, E., Menon, V., & Reiss, A. L. (2003). Humor modulates the mesolimbic reward centers. Neuron.

---

This concludes my two-part series on how I view the subject. I hope this exploration has shed light on what I find fascinating about humor, its social functions, and the ethical considerations that come with it. I might follow up with the anatomy of a joke, and what are its constituant parts.